Top Misconceptions About the Insanity Defense Debunked

April 24, 2025
By Lessem, Newstat & Tooson, LLP

When it comes to criminal law, few topics spark as much debate—or misunderstanding—as the insanity defense. Popularized by dramatic courtroom scenes in movies and TV shows, this legal strategy is often shrouded in myths that distort its true purpose and application. At Lessem, Newstat & Tooson, LLP, we believe in empowering our clients with accurate information to navigate the complexities of the legal system. Let’s debunk some of the most common misconceptions about the insanity defense and shed light on how it really works.

Misconception #1: The Insanity Defense Is a “Get Out of Jail Free” Card

One of the biggest myths is that claiming insanity allows defendants to walk free with no consequences. In reality, a successful insanity defense rarely leads to immediate freedom. When a defendant is found not guilty by reason of insanity (NGRI), they are typically committed to a psychiatric facility for treatment, often for a period equal to or longer than a prison sentence. The goal is to protect society while addressing the defendant’s mental health needs—not to let them off the hook.

Misconception #2: It’s Used All the Time

Thanks to its prominence in pop culture, many assume the insanity defense is a go-to strategy in criminal cases. However, it’s actually quite rare. Studies show that it’s raised in less than 1% of felony cases, and even then, it succeeds in only a fraction of those attempts—about 25% or less. At Lessem, Newstat & Tooson, LLP, our experienced attorneys know that this defense is a highly specialized option, reserved for cases with clear, compelling evidence of severe mental illness.

Misconception #3: Anyone Can Fake Insanity to Avoid Punishment

The idea that defendants can easily pretend, or temporarily portray a mental health condition, to dodge accountability oversimplifies the process. Courts rely on rigorous evaluations by mental health experts to determine if a defendant meets the legal standard for insanity—typically, whether they couldn’t understand the nature of their actions or distinguish right from wrong due to a mental disorder at the time of the crime. These assessments involve extensive interviews, psychological testing, and reviews of medical history, making it extremely difficult to deceive the system.

Misconception #4: The Insanity Defense Is the Same Everywhere

Not all jurisdictions define or handle the insanity defense the same way. In the United States, for example, different states use different assessment tools for mental health—like the M’Naghten Rule, the Model Penal Code standard, or the Durham Rule—to evaluate a defendant’s mental state. Some states have even abolished the insanity defense entirely, opting instead for “guilty but mentally ill” verdicts.

At Lessem, Newstat & Tooson, LLP, our team stays well-versed in California’s specific laws, ensuring our clients receive tailored, jurisdiction-specific guidance.

Misconception #5: It’s Only for Violent Crimes

While high-profile murder cases often come to mind, the insanity defense isn’t limited to violent offenses. It can apply to any crime— theft, fraud, or even minor offenses—if the defendant’s mental condition meets the legal threshold. The key is proving that a severe mental illness directly impaired their ability to form criminal intent, not the nature of the crime itself.

Misconception #6: A Diagnosis of Mental Illness Guarantees an Insanity Defense

Having a mental health condition doesn’t automatically qualify someone for this defense. The law draws a strict line: the mental illness must have directly caused the inability to understand the wrongfulness of the act or control their behavior at the time of the crime. Conditions like depression or anxiety, while serious, rarely meet this high bar unless they’re paired with psychosis or a similar debilitating disorder.

Our attorneys at Lessem, Newstat & Tooson, LLP work closely with experts to build a case that aligns with these stringent requirements.

Why Understanding the Insanity Defense Matters

The insanity defense exists to balance justice with compassion, recognizing that mental health can profoundly affect behavior. Yet, its complexity and rarity mean it’s often misunderstood by the public. Whether you’re facing criminal charges or simply seeking to understand your legal options, having accurate information is crucial.

At Lessem, Newstat & Tooson, LLP, our dedicated legal team is here to cut through the myths and provide clarity. If you or a loved one are navigating a case involving mental health concerns, we’re ready to offer legal guidance tailored to your unique situation.

Contact us today to learn more about how we can support you in pursuing the best possible outcome.

Categories

Related Posts

Can I Sue for a Slip-and-Fall at a National Park?

Slip-and-falls may not sound that serious, but falling accidents cause thousands of emergency room visits every year – and they frequently result in major injuries. While not every slip-and-fall accident will…

Read more...

The Difference Between Roadside and Evidentiary Breath Tests and What They Mean for Your DUI Case

DUI cases arise when an individual is accused of operating a vehicle under the influence or with an unlawful blood alcohol concentration. These charges are serious and can have significant legal…

Read more...

Certain Sex Offenders Can Now Be Relieved of Lifetime Registration

As of July 1, 2021, certain California residents who are required to register as sex offenders under Penal Code section 290 no longer have to satisfy the lifetime registration requirement.…

Read more...